Quality of life is something we all hold to be important,
personally, but which we usually do not assign much value to
in a business sense.
After all, most people like where they currently live and,
for companies in the process of comparing several different
locations in order to find the best site for their new
manufacturing facility or distribution center, QOL is a just a
“touchie-feelie” concept that really only takes on importance
if we are considering relocating senior management to the new
location. That’s why most companies place little or no value
on QOL during the site selection process.
Perhaps it’s time we looked at quality of life from an
entirely different angle.
What is quality of life? Does it mean access to cultural
amenities usually reserved for our largest cities? Does it
mean proximity to a major university? Access to major league
professional sports teams? Easy access to major recreational
offerings such as skiing, sailing or golf?
Or is it something more, something larger?
To us, quality of life means being able to afford to take
part in the “American Dream,” to be able to afford to buy the
average-priced home in your community and not feel “house
poor,” to be able to afford to rent a decent-sized apartment,
to feel safe and relatively free from crime, to be able to
send your children to good schools that will enable them to
better climb the ladder of success, to be able to spend the
lion’s sh are of your hard-earned income as you see fit, and
to not have to spend a major part of your day stuck in
bumper-to-bumper traffic.
That’s what quality of life really is all about. The
cultural amenities are important, but not nearly as important
as being able to live the American Dream – to raise your
family in a middle class lifestyle full of hope and
promise.
I know what you’re thinking – “That was beautiful, man, but
what does it have to do with my company?”
Two things: turnover and personnel costs.
First, let’s talk about turnover. People who are happy in
their lives are generally happy in their jobs, and that leads
to lower turnover, as well as to higher productivity. Lower
turnover also means lower training costs, lower recruitment
costs, etc. Fairly simple and straightforward, I think you’ll
agree.
The second point is personnel costs. In addition to the
recruitment and training costs mentioned above, it’s also
pretty much of a no-brainer that living costs, home values,
crime rates, etc. vary widely from community to community and
from state to state. If a salary of $35,000 will buy entry
into the “American Dream” in one community, while in another
it would take $45,000 to afford the same lifestyle, why on
earth would you, as a business owner, pick the more expensive
location?
Yeah, I know, the less expensive location may not have the
work force quality or quantity your company needs.
That’s why our Quality of Life QuotientTM doesn’t stop with
just housing affordability, peace of mind and cost of living.
We also include characteristics that you, as an employer, find
compelling as well.
We consider the education level of the adult population, as
well as the unemployment rate and the percentage of the work
force in the 18 to 35 age group. We also look at adult
education facilities — colleges and universities, as well as
community colleges — that will be able to provide your company
with the training facilities you’ll need to train your new
work force on the equipment and procedures you will use at its
new facility.
In the end, what we have come up with nine general
categories which, taken together, make up our annual Quality
of Life QuotientTM.
How We Organized the Categories
The first category we looked at is what we call “Peace of
Mind,” in which we attempt to measure the relative tranquility
of a particular metropolitan area.
This category consists of three basic elements: FBI violent
crime statistics, FBI property crime statistics and population
density. For those of you who might be in doubt, low crime
rates and low population density are good, high rates are bad,
at least in our opinion.
The second category we looked at is what we call
“Affordable Decent Housing.” In this category, we attempt to
measure the relative affordability of housing — both through
home ownership as well as renting — to the majority of the
population living in that metro.
We include the National Association of Home Builders’
“Housing Affordability Index,” which calculates the percentage
of the population that is able to afford to buy the
average-priced home in that particular metro.
We also include the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban
Development’s “Fair Market Rentals” list, which calculates the
average cost of a three- and four-bedroom apartment in various
communities throughout the United States.
The next area we looked at is the “Standard of Living,”
which attempts to measure financially how well the average
person lives in the various metros around the country.
Included in this category are comparisons in the median
family income, per capita income, cost of living indices,
unemployment rates, poverty rates, state and local tax rates
and per capita disposable income.
Other categories include “traffic congestion and safety,”
with data taken from the Federal Highway Administration, and
“air accessibility,” with data taken from the Federal Aviation
Administration.
From the employer’s standpoint, we looked at three
additional categories: adult education levels, adult
employability and continuing education.
“Adult Education” data, taken from the U.S. Census Bureau,
tries to get a general feel for the level of formal education
for the adult community. It includes the percentage of the
adult population over the age of 25 with at least a high
school diploma, as well as those over 25 with at least a
college degree.
Remember, what we’re looking for here is not a high
concentration of potential rocket scientists, but rather a
deep pool of potential manufacturing and logistics
workers.
“Adult Employability” attempts to get a feel for the cost
and availability of workers in various metro areas. This
category includes such things as average annual pay, average
wage per job and unemployment, as well as workers in the 18 to
35 age group.
Data for the final category, “Continuing Education,” is
taken from “Places Rated Almanac” and attempts to measure the
depth and variety of continuing education opportunities in
various communities throughout the country.
It includes the number of community colleges, as well as
colleges and universities offering degrees — B.A./B.S. through
Ph.D. Not only are these educational institutions important
for the opportunities they offer to the adult community at
large, but they are also important partners and service
deliverers for work force training incentives offered by each
of the 50 states.
What It All Means
Clearly, quality of life is much more than access to opera
or poetry readings. It’s more than gorgeous mountain vistas or
white sandy beaches. In truth, quality of life goes well
beyond nature’s blessings and the cultural amenities usually
reserved for our largest cities.
Quality of life is, like beauty, in the eyes of the
beholder. Being able to live and comfortably raise a family in
“middle class opulence” is really what the American Dream is
all about. When all is said and done, that’s the true meaning
of quality of life.